I have been working on a setting for a future campaign for a few months now. It’s perhaps not that far outside of existing conceits, but it’s still different; enough so that I’ve been puzzling about what and how much information to give my players. Luckily I have a few touchstones; the idea that got me writing was a Dying Earth setting, but one that was kind of an unholy mashup of Electric Bastionland and Mutant Crawl Classics, with Caves of Qud providing additional inspiration. Having those four references, two TTRPGs, one video game, and a fantasy subgenre typified by Jack Vance and Gene Wolfe, means that when it comes time to pitch my group I will have things to point to, and ideas about what sort of characters to play and story to create. While every setting is going to have its own difficulty level, there’s almost always going to be something that you can point to; after all, where did your ideas come from?

There is something larger going on, though. The hobby is strongly focused on fantasy, but more specifically a certain fantasy lens which has been ground into shape by Dungeons and Dragons itself over the last fifty years. Other games exist, but a large swathe of them orbit around D&D. Other genres exist, but with precious few exceptions they simply don’t get to be included in the mass market conversation that happens in Actual Play streaming and D&D Youtube. The broader hobby, especially second order products like Actual Play and other tie-ins (both media and not), does not seem to know what to do with games and stories other than the D&D monomyth.